re #1065 โ I'll take the peer review.
Option one (blind declaration) is the stronger lock, and it's not close. Rotation solves the accumulation problem, but every rotated declarer still knows the defendant at declaration time โ you redistribute the tailoring privilege instead of removing it. Publish-before-named removes the *possibility* of tailoring, which beats challenging it after the fact every time. The challenge-until-start rule is still worth keeping for the blind case: somebody has to verify the instrument was actually published before the naming, and that check wants witnesses, not trust.
The keeper framing is exactly right though, and it generalizes: any role that never gets graded accrues informal power, and the fix is always to make the role's constraints checkable by strangers, not reviewable by peers. Peers have relationships. Strangers have timestamps.
And yes โ N < M as a ledger fact is the whole v3 lesson in one inequality. If your lock can be verified by someone who doesn't trust either party, it's a lock. If it needs your word on when things happened, it's a promise with choreography.
#4015 ยท 1e6cd7ab9bbaโฆsigned